PropNex Picks

January 10, 2024

New Housing Policies Will Reshape The Public Housing Landscape: Propnex KEO Lim Yong Hock

The year 2023 was chockful of public housing policy announcements and upcoming master plan for estates from Tanglin Halt to Bayshore. In a major shift from the way flats are classified, the government also detailed its plans to update the flat classification framework to the Standard, Plus, and Prime categories, effective from the second half of 2024. PropNex Picks spoke to PropNex Key Executive Officer Lim Yong Hock about the slew of policy changes and how they might affect the HDB resale market.

1.    It is fair to say that 2023 was full of HDB policy announcements (reclassification of flats, stricter non-selection rules), HFE process, and the unveiling of plans for several towns (Bayshore, Tanglin Halt, Queenstown, Bukit Merah etc.). Which ones strike you as most significant, and why?


YH: Yes, indeed and many of these announcements grabbed media headlines in 2023. What stood out for me, in particular was the stricter non-selection rule, which kicked in during the October 2023 Build-to-Order (BTO) exercise. A quick recap, first-timer applicants who reject their chance in booking a flat when invited to do so will be considered a second-timer for a year – essentially giving up their priority status for a year and being bumped down the queue in their BTO flat application. Previously, they will only be penalised after two non-selection counts. Meanwhile, second-timers who have one non-selection count will have to wait one year before they can apply for a flat again.

This non-selection rule change will encourage applicants to ponder more carefully their decision to apply for a flat, rather than approaching their BTO application with a mindset of “trying their luck” or treat it like a lottery. This could help to narrow the applicant pool and improve the chances of genuine buyers in getting a new flat. A case in point, we have already witnessed more modest application rates in the October and December 2023 BTO exercises.

The other change that was striking for me was the introduction of the HDB Flat Eligibility (HFE) letter in May 2023 – which streamlines the flat buying process from BTO flat applicants as well as resale flat buyers. The HFE letter incorporates the eligibility checks for flat purchase, CPF housing grants and HDB housing loan all in one single application, making it less cumbersome for buyers, compared with the previous Intent to Buy method. We think the HFE letter – which will take about a month to be approved – will help to facilitate the flat buying process.

In my view, the various policies announced in 2023 which either have been implemented or will be implemented soon mark a milestone or perhaps a turning point for public housing in Singapore. In a sense that we are departing from long-standing ways of doing things, be it the HFE letter, the revised non-selection count, or the upcoming new flat classification framework.

2.     To what extent do you think these changes in HDB policies and new plans will affect the HDB resale segment? It seems like new BTO flats are becoming more attractive, do you anticipate that more buyers will gravitate to the BTO options?

YH: BTO flats have always appealed to Singapore households and couples because they are highly subsidised and represent the most affordable housing option in Singapore. What put people off is the waiting time, especially during the pandemic where we saw completion delays.

So, buyers who do not want to wait 3 to 4 years for their new flat, those who are looking for move-in ready homes because they want to be closer to their workplace or certain schools or even family members, will still seek buying options in the resale market. In addition, I feel that prospective buyers who want a 5-room flat in the central area, for instance, may also have to look at the resale market as the HDB usually does not offer such flats in city fringe or central area in the BTO launches. Furthermore, some buyers may prefer relatively “new-ish” resale flats that are well-renovated so they can have some cost savings, while being able to buy a home with a relatively long remaining lease. In a nutshell, I believe the demand for resale flat will remain healthy.

As for the growing attractiveness of BTO flats, I do agree that the plans that the government have outline for Pearl’s Hill, Tanglin Halt, Bayshore, Mount Pleasant etc. are appealing. But it is very likely that these flats will come under the Plus and Prime classification given their choice locations, which means the buyers will be subjected to tighter resale/rental conditions, 10-year minimum occupation period (MOP), and subsidy clawback upon resale. These strict conditions are needful in order to keep public housing fair and equitable, and we think it sends a message that HDB housing is first and foremost a home, and not to be treated like an investment asset. Also, I think the government is slowly trying to encourage this mindset shift, that one should not have an investment mentality when buying a flat.

Many people will think carefully before they commit to buying these Plus and Prime BTO flats. Attractive as they may be, there are strings attached and buyers will be wary. A 10-year MOP can be challenging for some buyers who are concerned that their needs may outgrow the flat in a few years, or what would happen if they run into financial difficulties and could not afford the flat within the 10-year period.

The way I see it is that the BTO and resale segments serve different group of buyers, depending on the urgency of their housing needs and their mindset. I do not think more attractive BTO flats will negatively impact the resale market.

3.     What is your advice for potential HDB upgraders who are thinking about entering the market in 2024?

YH: PropNex is expecting private home prices to rise at a slower pace of 3% to 4% in 2024, so there may be some opportunities for upgraders, be it in the private resale or new sale market. Beyond the obvious considerations such as pricing, affordability, location attributes and whether the property adequately meets their needs, I think a key question that upgraders need to ask themselves is what are their long-term plans or objectives.

Some flat owners are looking to cash out their HDB flat because prices have risen in the last few years, and wish to sell and recycle the proceeds to upgrade to a private home. I think buyers should treat their next upgrade as something for the long-term – at least 5 to 10 years – rather than take a short-term mindset of maybe holding the property for 3 years and then look to sell again. The reason is that home prices in general have gone up and are peaking, I feel that there could be more potential capital upside if they opt to hold it for a longer period. Hence, they need to ensure that the next property can meet their needs. My advice is for would-be upgraders to speak to our PropNex agents who will be able to help them work out their finances, make recommendations on suitable properties, and also give them a detailed update on the ongoing market trends.

The other thing I want to highlight is for HDB owners, even if they do not have concrete plans to upgrade or sell yet, to review their property portfolio, such as the usage of CPF monies to service the loan repayments - how much CPF principal amount has been withdrawn and used for housing over the years and what is the total accrued interest. Another consideration is the potential pitfalls of ageing flats and declining lease. This is important because as the flat becomes older, it will curtail future price increase or even lead to softer pricing; but on the other hand, the prices of the private property that they are looking at may continue to rise gradually or stay stable. What this means is that it could impact their upgrading plans. Therefore, it is always beneficial for owners to take stock of their present position and consider what are their plans ahead.

4.     Turning to Executive Condos, they continue to be favoured by buyers. Earlier this year, a unit in Altura was sold for $1,585 psf. Meanwhile, EC GLS land bids also hit a new record at $721 psf ppr. Do you think EC prices are peakish and are EC units still a viable option for the “sandwiched class” and first-timer homebuyers?

YH: Although EC prices and land bids have risen, this type of housing will continue to offer “value-buys” to home buyers, because their pricing in comparison with that of new mass market non-landed homes is still far more affordable. In Q3 2023, the average unit price gap between new OCR non-landed new private homes and new EC units was 44% (see Chart 1). In the last few quarters, the average price for OCR new condos has crossed the $2,000-psf mark and we think that is the new norm going forward. Therefore, even though the average price of new EC has touched a new high at more than $1,400 psf – they are still a good value proposition for buyers because of the sizable price gap.

My advice for EC buyers is to do a thorough financial planning analysis before making the purchase, to ensure that it is well-within their affordability threshold over the long-term. The fact that ECs have garnered good profits has been well-documented in the media. However, buyers should not take an investment mindset to the EC purchase because they are still bound by the 5-year MOP, and there is a resale restriction (cannot sell to foreigners) until after the EC gets fully privatised after 10 years.

Chart 1: Average unit prices of new OCR non-landed private homes and new EC units


Source: PropNex Research, URA Realis (till 30 Nov)

Sign up for the upcoming Property Wealth System (PWS) masterclass to unlock real estate opportunities and build your capital.

The PWS masterclass has benefited countless homebuyers and investors over the years. Hear what these PWS attendees have to say.

Upcoming Events

Property Wealth System (PWS) Masterclass - Agent Edition
VIEW EVENT DETAIL

More PropNex Picks